![]() |
The Manhattan Beach Neighborhood Association (MBNA) held its first meeting at P.S. 195 and was well attended by 150 to 200 people. After a brief introduction by the president Alan Ditchek he introduced Brooklyn district attorney Charles Hynes. Hynes welcomed the group and introduced a speaker to talk about teen online safety.
Although the Online Safety presentation was informative and interactive, you usually don’t see these kinds of speakers at local civic meetings. The presenter who usually goes to schools and talks to children was now talking to an audience where the average age was in the 50’s. People were commenting that their children are now in their 30’s. It was still a good source of information. I was glad to draw a laugh as the one guy in the back with his hand raised for having a myspace page. (Oh and next time set the laptop resolution, not the projector resolution set before you begin.)
![]() |
NYPD 61 Precinct Captain Georgios Mastrokostas was there to re-introduce himself to Manhattan Beach and to briefly talk about his summer patrol plans for the community and to wish the new group good luck.
Now came the real introduction from Alan Ditchek: he thanked Ira Zalcman for dismissing him so he and others can start this new group. He then went on to talk about his qualifications to be president, commenting about how long he’s been in Manhattan beach and his memories of the area. He also said he wasn’t going to have any secret meetings, no back door decisions, no clicks, and no verbal intimidation
Afterwards P.S. 195′s principal, Arthur Forman, sang the theme song to Mr. Rogers, which I’m not going to lie was a bit creepy. He congratulated the new group for striving to maintain the beauty and character of the neighborhood.
Councilman Mike Nelson said multiple times that there were 350 people in attendance, which is not close at all to the actual number. I counted at around 155 with maybe 175 at its peak. It’s very clear that Councilman Mike Nelson is very much a part of this new group, organizing the meeting and even thanking his wife for being apart of it. He stated that he will be going to both community meetings as much as his schedule permits.
![]() |
Everyone was sworn in by Councilman Mike Nelson. Members of the MBCG board include Alan Ditchek, Ron Biondo, Al Smaldone, Albert Hasson, Edmund Dweck, Michael Troupt, Vicki Klur, and Arthur Gershfeld. There are 13 total board members but I’m missing 5 because I have no idea how to spell their names.
Dozens signed up for the new group at the end of the meeting.
The Manhattan Beach Community Group had a prepared response:
The Manhattan Beach Community Group (MBCG) is your neighborhood group for the past 67 years that has been fighting to maintain the beauty and character of your neighborhood.
We want to continue to make Manhattan Beach the safest, cleanest and best neighborhood to live in.
All you have to do is mail us a check with your name and address for $25 payable to MBCG at 214 Beaumont Street.The Greater our numbers the Greater our voice.
Links







What exactly has Mike Nelson done for his constituents? When you read the papers and see comments from other council members, his name is never mentioned as if he is a ghost….I dont feel he has served this community but rather himself….I see all the new apartments going up where once single family homes stood…the area is starting to look like Manhattan and is too congested.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
I have to tell you someday how I’m almost, but not quite, related to Alan Ditchek. A very cool guy.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Thanked his wife, good grief. What a hack couple they are.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Mike Nelson has the coolest, most daring, sorta realistic, grooviest hair ever on the city council! I want to thank his hair for putting the squash on the congestion tax.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
It was the best meeting I have attended in MB in the last 20 years.
GREAT to see such a group of really committed people who care about bringing their community together as real neighbors.
A refreshing change from the old guard….this is the best thing that has happened for MB in many years.True Democracy at work.
350 PEOPLE WOW..WHAT A GREAT START,CONGRATULATIONS MBNA
Like or Dislike:
0
0
You can clearly see in the picture that there is not 350 people.
From the picture looks like more than 350 people the room is packed plus others standing what are you looking at ?????
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Apparently you cant count at all, because when I was there at the meeting I counted…twice and I still came up with the same number.
Just for the lulz I put little red dots on all of the people there in my picture that you clearly see 300+ people in.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/gerritsenbeach/2402949952/
by coincidence there are exactly 150 red dots on these people. Now because we cant see everyone lets say we add 30 for a total of 180, then with people leaving early and such lets round it up to 200. Adding 50 people is generous and now I just feel bad for you because you never learned to count.
Learn to count then come back to the rest of the class.
I mean come on look at all of those empty seats.
Nice response GB.net. I think you are debating counting with some dope from Nelson’s staff or the man himself. What a hack. He has never done a thing in the council, zero achievements.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
To the folks who said Nelson has done nothing and has zero achievements…I totally agree….he isnt even friendly to his neighbors…has a zero personality..why do folks vote for him?I am curious what he will do with Term Limits in effect.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
350 is A LOT of people. It is obviously much less than that.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
The question begs to be asked. . . what does any of this have to do with Gerritsen Beach?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
While there may only have been 150-175 physically present, with a few more early departures and yet-to-arrives not counted, countless others, like myself, couldn’t make it but were there in spirit. Councilman Nelson, being a gifted clairvoyant and political prognosticator, knew this, and so his calculated, albeit unverifiable, estimate is correct and even a bit conservative. If even more people show up next month to fill those empty seats, Nelson will be seen as a true visionary. But it’s good that he’s not the City Comptroller.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Nelson is a do nothing hack. Every other day his excuse for him doing nothing is his wife’s illness. Now all of sudden she a “special adviser” to MBNA. What in the world does a sick wife of a do nothing councilman able to advise anyone on. Sheila and Mike are really becoming senile. I feel bad for the poor staff members that need jobs and have to work with those crazy self centered, money stealing hacks.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Anonymous, did you say this to Mr. Nelson’s face or just behind the safety of your computer screen? I would like to be there if you have the guts to tell him he is a money stealing hack to his face. Come back on, identify yourself, and lets go to the next meeting to address this. You know so much about him you should know where he will be next. Got the guts?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Don’t even get me started, it is Nelson who lacks guts, and he is stealing our money by actually collecting a city taxpayer funded salalry of over $120,000. All for what? He achomplishes nothing except giving out the basic allowance of member items that any freshman legislator could get.
Most of this money goes to groups that also pay Chaim Deutsch of Nelson’s staff.
Deutsch (rumored to be contemplating a run for Mikey boys seat) is only on nelson’s staff in name and salary only. Truth is he never has completed a time sheet or fulfilled his “hours” in a legal way.
As a tax payer i consider this stealing our money, don’t you?
Great reporting GB.net. Not to take the expression from Fox news but you reported and I decided for myself. Hope others can too.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Anonymous you seem to have some kind of problem with Mr Nelson anytime we need things done MR Nelson and his staff is always here for us and Mr Nelson is always able to help us with any problems we may have.
MR Nelson IS ONE OF THE BEST COUNCILMAN we have had in a very long time.
The way we talk about Mr Nelson and his wife “YOU SHOULD BE ASHAME OF YOURSELF”
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Not to complain but, who voted for Sheila?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
“Don’t get me started”, you started it. Don’t come here anonymously smearing someone’s name and reputation, accusing them of stealing, etc. and not say who you are. Stop hiding behind the screen and roll up those sleeves big boy.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Smearing the Nelson name and reputation? Come you have got to be kidding me! They are not even a real married couple. They make the Clintons look wholesome.
Councilman Nelson is a senile, embarrasssing thief. He does not work for our area. Just walk up into his office, or heck even try to call. The Councilman is never available to his constituents unless they ahve donated money to him.
For example the Sahara restraunt. Which was overwhelmingly rejected by the Community Board, includind Sheila Nelson.
Ironically the Conflicts of Interest Board is investigating said actions because a Councilmembers wife is not supposed to vote on Community Board matters that are in the district the spouse represents.
Furthermore to make matters look even more strange after Nelson had the matter quickly passed by the council it was uncovered that he has taken in thousand of dollars in donations from the Family that runs the Sahara.
Nelson was even on the record as saying he was against the project, then after some money changed hands he changed his mind.
Boy oh Boy. We have a Councilman who does nothing but take money for him and his chosen predescor, and furthermore has his wife on the Communtiy Board voting in matters that the NYC Conflict of Interest Board has said she should not be involved in. Tssk Tssk.
But hey I guess since I am anonymous it means I am wrong. Try again. The wandering councilman and his power hungry wife should hit the road before term limits or an indictment force them out.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Anonymous….keep up the good work….if it weren’t for folks like you telling the real truth, we would never know where our tax dollars are going….I was wondering how the Nelson’s could afford those two new shiny cadillacs.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Ask Sheila about her “personal affair” with Norma Chesler!
Like or Dislike:
0
0
You just don’t get it do you? They may be all of those things but by coming here with it and anonymously at that, you look worse then they do. Either state your real name and real facts or don’t post. Any weasel can come here and make up all the crap they want whether it is true or not. You look like a whiny jealous crybaby.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
AnonAnon, I learned a lot here in a few days…and I dont see you posting your real name….why is that?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
If anyone said their name, would that mean you know them?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Oh so ur real name is “nosy”? I am not posting my name because I am not coming here making accusations against politicians that work for our community. I wouldn’t come here like a little coward hiding behind “anonymous” and stating call anyone names unless I posted my name and can say it to their face. Whats wrong with you nosy that you can’t see that isn’t right. If I knew you had done something illegal I wouldn’t come here posting YOUR real name and then I remain anonymous. If I had the guts to call you out I would have the guts to post my real name, not accuse and hide.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
To pick_ur_nosy…
DUHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Anonymous you are showing how big of a ASS you
Like or Dislike:
0
0
JOjo….and you?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Corrupt Politicians who do no work should be embarrassed and lose their jobs.
Nelson needs to stop pretending he actually does anything, and stop having his staff post lame defenses of him here.
First it was Brooklyn’s Kendall Stewart that his staffers indicted for phone funding scams, next is Councilman Nelson and his staffer, Chaim Deutsch.
A prison suit will flatter you Nelson. Maybe you could play your wife’s cancer card again so you can avoid being active.
NEWSFLASH…..you do not even attend communtiy meetings unless your wife brings you along to a CB15 meeting. Where at that meeting you will pace around the back very nervously, avoiding to say anything meaningful or nice to anyone.
Then we are lucky enough to hear you speak for 3 mintues about nothing. Beacuse you do nothing. I think you only get your information about City Hall by skimming the newspaper. No deep thought, just old senile ramblings.
Now quick have your staff write a reply on this web site, so you can waste more tax payer money
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Woo hoo, that last one was good..and lets be honest, in the many years Mr Nelson been our councilman, what significant improvements if any have you seen in our general community?
AnonAnon you asked for real facts…here is a fact…Ever look at the Sheepshead Bay and Neck Road subway stations…including the surrounding filthy streets…maybe if he took a walk around the area he would see what needs to be cleaned up. There are other messy spots but he most likely never walks around to see the quality of life improvements that can be made. The Avenue U streets by the subway are a major disgrace and rats are common. I dont think I need to contact his office directly to complain about this type of issue…a Councilman should know his district and I think he is selective in who he serves. Also if I were him, I would be interested in what my constituents think of my job performance whether negative or positive especially if I wanted to move on to higher office…sometimes criticism is the basis for the road to improvement.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Oh goodness, with nice new shiny Cadillacs like me and my wife Sheila have why would we ever want to go mingle with the dreck that uses the Subway. Besides someone might actually stop and speak to Sheila or myself which lord knows might expose me for a senile do nothing hack. Now stop typing about me on this infernal blog, I must make it to a 2 o’clock lunch, or as I say breakfast since I am working so hard sleeping late and doing nothing but earning a six figure salary to do nothing.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Once again MB uses GB site to try & spread their propoganda crap. FYI GB does not give a flying —– about MB. Find your own space.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Anonymous …what a big ass you are to stoop so low as to mention someones health issues…you are a very very disturbed person to even speak in such a manner….the nelson’s have been nothing but helpful to the communties he represents….maybe one day you will suffer for your loshon hora (evil tongue) ….g-d bless the nelsons and g-d bless america!!!!
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Woo hoo, that last one was really good.
And nosy, instead of just being nosy, why don’t you call 311 for the dirt and rats, that’s what your supposed to do.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
I would agree with you that bringing up someone’s health is not kosher, however I am not the one using it as an excuse. If she is sick, then why is it that he does not have to do anything at work. If that happened to you or me we would lose our jobs. Not Councilman Mike, he does not have to show up for his job.
What is the matter Mikey? Carl Kruger does not tell you what to do anymore, instead Chaim Deutsch gets your payoffs for you.
Uh she has me on a medical, and I was called an ass. What a hack. Nelson is a hack.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Anonymous you are going right to “HELL” talking about peoples health. How would you feel the day you have health problems and no one from your family is there to help you ????
If any member in your family is having any health problems ..any normal person would be there doing everything they can to help them, but looks like you you do not know about this.
SO looks like you are going RIGHT TO “HELL”
Like or Dislike:
0
0
LMAO, you savior killing kite. Who is going to hell?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
I thought I was done here but..nosytoo….the purpose of 311 is not to provide the services we are already paying for with our tax dollars…this includes street sweeping, pick ups of litterbaskets and tickets to stores as well as individuals who litter. Also maybe additional pickups are needed….would this be an issue for our councilman?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Nosy, the Chinese are filthy. That is why Ave. U is dirty. Before they moved in it was clean. Ever walk through Chinatown and little Italy? Little Italy is clean and Chinatown is a filthy disgrace with horrible smells.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Clearly Italians are better than Chinese
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Senility is a sad disease, thank god for term limits.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
I agree with nosytoo, call 311 and quit your badmouthing.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
why dont you folks stop complaining and move somewhere else. preferably back to your own country.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Hey ASS-ANONYMOUS
Like or Dislike:
0
0
mike nelson for president!
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Who is Norma Chesler? I know a Norman Chesler
This comment is directed to “Anonymous”, I am Norman not NORMA Chesler and I am alive, well and kicking. I am enjoying reading all your pro and con comments which I would know better than most of you since I have been involved in politics for more than 30 years). Regarding most of all your comments,I must admit your very close on the mark.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Boy’s and girls, lets talk about another political family which just so happens to be related to each other. Lew Fidler and his wife are related to Michael Garson and his wife(sisters) it’s like the Hatfields and McCoys clan war.While this saga continues, I hear that Doreen Garson a democrat is working for a republican politician, I do not understand this move!.
Oh by the way former Judge Howard Ruditsky has never been my cousin as stated by Michael Garson and no money had ever been paid to Clarence Norman by ME for Ruditsky. Now the truth as I know it will be forthcoming.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
ANONYMOUS: How can Sheila Nelson be a special advisor to MBNA? I thought you need to reside in MB. She does not., so this means her husband placed her there. Is she getting paid?
What are her duties?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
HEY Norman were are you in jail ?? I don’t know they give you computers to use in the pen.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
BigJJ: Why don’t you take down your mask and tell the site your name or are you just littlejj?
no ignorant one , I never was in jail and they do in fact have computers in jails,and you know what, the pen is mightier than the sword and littlejj you keep sending your comments and I will enjoy answering each and every and one of them
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Maybe you people need to air your dirty laundry somewhere else. You all think you are so called experts on other people’s lives but you don’t know jack.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
hi AnonAnon(sheila) just so happens I am an expert and have an awful lot of knowledge on other peoples lives. Want to test me??
Like or Dislike:
0
0
you just failed.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
This is all so childish. I can’t believe that people purporting to be community activists, or, at least, concerned community residents, are wasting their time sniping at each other about such inanities. It’s one thing to criticize Mike Nelson, as he’s fair game. But this adolescent “I know you are, but what am I” crap is embarassing. Please grow up, guys, and show this blog the dignity it deserves for all the hard work that goes into keeping us informed.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
This is great. If that really is Norman Chesler then this is freaking awesome.
I totally know that Sheila and her “good” friend Deborah Miller Weiss (btw who is employed by nelson and formerly worked for Norman Chesler) are monitoring this blog and the SBPB blog.
Sheila and or her daughter Bonnie (Mike’s Step Daughter who resides in New Jersey but votes in New York) also blog on the SBPB site under RUkidding me and Spanky.
For anyone who knows anything about the Nelson’s or their shady funding scams, knows that this stuff right here is gold.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
If that really is Norman then tell us all how MIke cheated on Sheila, and she had an affair with Norman Chesler. Public Record….look it up. Nelson has clearly admitted inthe past that at one point him and his wife were seperated.
(To some that may have gone over the line, but if Mike Nelson and his wife want to collect hundreds of thousands of dollars from the tax payers, then they had better be prepared to answer some questions.
Way to go Norman, please come back and give us some more. I bet Sheila is afraid and can not stop talking about this to everyone. LMAO
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Dear fellow bloggers: I was not the individual who wrote
“you just failed” signed by Norma Chisler. You know only 2 people ever called me that and now I will put my thinking hat on and expose you to>. This is one game I will not lose.
And if you ask why am I doing this, I will let you all know soon.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Be careful dude. I don’t know what your pissed about, but I understand your anger. Think before you do something you regret.
I’m going to be watching and laughing if/when you drop your bomb.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
The bomb that I intend to drop will be an atomic bomb.. . As you know an investigation was done by the Brooklyn DA and poof all my friends walked away from me including the nelsons of 20 years., plus everyone who I was very good to.. Now its my turn .For 15 years I was part of the inner circle and this allowed me to hear and view things the average person is not aware. You could watch all you want and laugh until your side spits, but I will have the last laugh.The DAs investigation was one sided (isn’t blogging fun) for the record .
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Who cares, go start your own blog.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
isn’t doreen garson a greenwood?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
To Anon) You reguested that I start my own blog??> I am sure that can be arranged or simply go gene berridelli site and speak the truth about you and every personal (present ,and past) friends including relativeswho have you and your husband helped quietly.
How many people out there know Mike Nelson true middle name and where did he get it from. Now lets play truth and consequences. Alol becauseyou want me me to start my own blog
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Dude, drop your bomb…say what you want to say….or stop commenting.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Stop playing games
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Hey Norman have any postage stamps ???? about $ 6,000 worth
Like or Dislike:
0
0
to bigjj: I sure do part of those went to the tj club–did u
get any of it??
Like or Dislike:
0
0
have you noticed that the word “DUDE” is being said by 2 differebnt people??? One is”donald as in WEBER (maybe) and anonymous ???
And regarding the “bomb” I’ll deciede when it will be dropped
I have great ammunition dating back from1975 to the present Is this ok with you DUDES!!!
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Julie, can you provide the link to SBPB blog so we can read up? thanks
Also does anyone know where one can get a list of the charitable groups Mike Nelson has funded as councilman?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
besides giving some mor-ney to the libraries,MB holocaust,cleaning up the bay and graffittee removal. The rest his major contributions are given on a loop(jewishRE owners
TRIVIA QUESTION: wHAT PAID AND UNPAID JOBS have DO CHAIM DEUTSCHdo for Mike Nelson?? Thid will help nosy somewhat.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
i love you nosy.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
http://www.sbpbcivic.org
Like or Dislike:
0
0
HEY Normen were are the rolls of postage stamps ….maybe we need to talk to Rudy about this
Like or Dislike:
0
0
I love it. Norman you are the man! Calling out the TJ club and Nelson on the stamps is great. What about Nelson’s first victory party that you picked up the tab for, or does Sheila have another story for that one.
Mike’s middle name is Chaim btw. Sen. Carl Kruger gave it to Mike as a gift to help him look Jewish.
So do you really think Mike and or Chaim are going to be indicted?
I guess this means Terry Scavo is a shoe in to replace Mike. I think that is awesome. Terry is smart and works hard. Unlike Nelson who is a thief and corrupt. Like CHaim Deutsch is ever even in his office. I think I might have to send the council some FOIL requests for time sheets. BTW all city employees have their salaries listed publiclly. Guess how much CHaim makes???? I will be back later with the link. If you want to search on your own go the the Daily News Politics Blog and it is listed in a rundown piece . You might have to read through for it.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Who cares? If u want to air their dirty laundry go to the meetings and confront them face to face, cowards.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
With that comments are closed on this post.